Van Gogh’s masterpiece sold for $190.4 million, surpassing the artist’s previous $117.2 million record, after an ownership dispute settlement.
The sale, which marked the end of an eleventh-hour ownership dispute, saw the masterpiece become the fourth most expensive painting ever sold at public auction.
It had not been viewed publicly for half a century, serving as the highlight of a 12-piece collection assembled by the late Argentine sugar heiress Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier and her husband, Carlos Pedro Blaquier. Sotheby’s senior adviser Simon Shaw said that the collection possessed an “almost mythical status,” describing the group as more akin to a miniature Musée d’Orsay than a private holding.
An 11th-Hour Settlement Over Nazi-Era Duress
The auction was thrown into chaos just days before the scheduled event when descendants of the painting’s former owner, German Jewish publisher Samuel Fischer, staked a claim to the work.
Auctioneer Oliver Barker receives white gloves after 100% of lots sell in Legendary: The Blaquier-Arrieta Collection. This historic collection of masterworks achieved $412 million tonight at #SothebysNewYork. The collection of Modern and Impressionist paintings was led by a… pic.twitter.com/ixe2jQAV1s
According to historical records, the family had entrusted the Van Gogh and two Cézanne works to the Paul Cassirer gallery in Amsterdam in 1932 or 1933. By 1936, the painting was sold to a Parisian collector, eventually passing through several owners before being acquired by the Blaquier-Arrieta family in 1975.
However, following a marathon negotiating session on the Monday prior to the auction, the heirs and the Blaquier-Arrieta family reached a mutually satisfactory resolution. While the auction house declined to disclose the specific terms of the agreement, the settlement allowed the sale to proceed.

A Collection Under Scrutiny
The auction of the Blaquier-Arrieta collection faced additional scrutiny beyond the Van Gogh. Christie’s had previously flagged another lot, Maurice de Vlaminck’s 1906 Nature morte à la cruche bleue, as high-risk due to its appearance on the “Vollard List” of works stolen during the Nazi era.
Furthermore, the late patriarch Carlos Pedro Blaquier had faced long-standing allegations regarding his company’s role in the detention of people during Argentina’s military dictatorship in the 1970s. Although he faced charges in 2012, the case never reached trial before his death in 2023.
The Van Gogh’s final price of $190.4 million surpassed the artist’s previous record of $117.2 million, set in 2022 for Orchard with Cypresses from the estate of Paul Allen. The total for all 12 paintings in the Blaquier-Arrieta collection reached almost $412 million.
Other notable lots in the sale included works by Claude Monet and Pierre-Auguste Renoir, with Monet’s Le Jardin des Tuileries fetching $20.23 million and Renoir’s En Canot (Jeune fille à la barque) selling for $27.5 million.

Earlier coverage: Sotheby's Sells Van Gogh Painting for Record $190.4 Million