Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson were eliminated from Dancing With the Stars on November 17 despite perfect semifinal scores.
The pair danced a paso doble to Rihanna and Calvin Harris’s We Found Love and a quickstep to the Glee arrangement of Valerie, a tribute to Shum’s late costar Naya Rivera. Both routines drew 10s from every judge — Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough, and Bruno Tonioli — for a combined 60 out of 60. The public vote sent them home one week before the finale.
“I oddly feel at ease. I don’t feel sad—it’s really weird.” Shum told E! “I kind of felt like we accomplished everything we wanted to.” “We had concocted this incredible journey that the ballroom won’t see this time.” “But maybe we’ll put it out there somewhere.” she told E! News.
Harry dancing to Naya’s GLEE arrangement of Valerie had me in tears! The tribute to the dance with Hemo?!!🥹😭 #DWTS
The Valerie Tribute
Shum confirmed before the show that the quickstep would use the Glee arrangement of Valerie, performed live by the DWTS band — not Rivera’s original vocals. Rivera, who played Santana Lopez, sang the song in season 2 at Sectionals and again in season 5. She died in July 2020 at age 33.
“I wanted to also just clarify, I've seen you guys' excitement from 'Valerie,'” Shum said in an Instagram Story Entertainment Weekly reported.
I am finally done watching DWTS..to not have Harry & Jenna in the finale is absolutely ridiculous!! They have been the best week after week hands down. Tatyana or Conner never should have made it ahead of Harry. What a waste of watching this season!!
“And it's so much fun. It's so much fun to hear it. And, you know, what we made sure to get is the Glee version to be able to hear the [a cappella moments].” After the dance, he pointed toward the sky and blew a kiss, telling co-host Julianne Hough, “We miss you, baby girl.”
Rivera performed Valerie twice during Glee‘s six-season run from 2009 until 2015. Santana Lopez first sang the track when New Directions competed at Sectionals in season 2, and later revisited the song during season 5. Shum, who portrayed Mike Chang on the Fox musical series, said the song meant so much to so many people and recalled, “It was a moment where you kind of saw the underdog be able to have the spotlight, and I always remember that feeling.” He added that Dancing With the Stars is “synonymous with Glee” and that dancing to the arrangement meant a great deal to him and the fans.
YALL ELIMINATED HARRY ARE YOU KIDDING ME AFTER THAT NAYA TRIBUTE #dwts IS RIGGED!!!!
Shum also teased the possibility of another routine with Johnson on their own terms, saying, “It would have been nice to do a finale, but I think we’ll have our own finale in some sort of way, shape, or form in the future.”
In a February 2025 episode of the Call It What It Is podcast, Shum said he has rewatched Glee since the deaths of Rivera, Cory Monteith, and Mark Salling, and is able to find joy in the time they shared on screen.
He said the experience “needs to stay, but it's a matter of how you kind of do the back and forth — the dance — with the joy [from]…the memories you did have.”
Season Marked by Chaos
Both Shum and Johnson described season 35 as unusually turbulent. Chmerkovskiy apologized to Inaba on October 15. “I should never have made the reference that I did and I deeply regret it.” Dewan, 45, told Women’s Health that she “did not foresee having as many challenges as I did that were thrown at me during my Dancing with the Stars journey” in an interview published after her elimination.

“There’s a lot of trauma bond just because this year has been a little crazy,” Dewan said.
“Social media is a little nuts. I hope they address that at a certain point, because I think there’s a good amount of bullying that doesn’t feel really good, and I think the rest of the cast feels it,” he told People.
Johnson agreed the cast was “all trauma-bonded” from the experience. Shum added that he hoped to get to know his fellow competitors more outside the ballroom, saying, “I hope to get to know them more.”
The remaining five couples — Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov, Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold, Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach, Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas, and Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik — will face off in the season 35 finale on Tuesday, November 24, airing live on ABC and Disney+.
Shum offered a parting message to the finalists: “You are good enough.” “You deserve to be where you’re at.” “Love this experience, and I think we’ve all been able to do something really incredible in our own way.” Dancing With the Stars airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and streams the next day on Hulu.
As for Shum and Johnson, both signaled the partnership won’t end at the ballroom door. “I want to make more art with her, and that’s what it’s really about,” Shum said.
“I like making art that people enjoy. So, to me, I felt that energy [in] the people that I did see and the people that really loved what we were able to do in this dance. I’m now a trained dancer because of her.”