“Everybody tells me he’s outstanding, and he’s being held up by John Cornyn because John Cornyn’s feelings were hurt,” President Donald Trump told Fox News’ “Saturday in America”.
The president’s comments escalate a public feud with the outgoing Texas senator, who has effectively blocked the nomination of T. Elliot Gaiser to a federal district court seat in Dallas.
The Blue Slip Standoff
By withholding this support, the senator has halted the nomination process for Gaiser, a 37-year-old official currently leading the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel. The blue slip gives senators significant veto power over court picks, and without it, a nomination cannot advance through the Senate Judiciary Committee.
If President Trump wanted to fill a judicial vacancy in Dallas, why did he wait until after the midterms to nominate someone? The seat has been vacant since 2025. Then, without any consultation, he nominates a non-Texan with little connection to the Lone Star State, with no…
Explaining his decision, Cornyn told The Associated Press that the nominee lacks sufficient ties to the state. “He’s not from Texas. He hasn’t been vetted. And this is a lifetime job, and there’s better-qualified people to hold that job,” he said. He added that he refuses to be “jammed” by a candidate who lacks trial experience.
Cornyn has instead pushed for the confirmation of Steve Fahey, a former federal prosecutor in the Northern District of Texas, arguing that the White House failed to consult with him before selecting Gaiser. Cornyn noted in an interview that the White House now appears to be showing interest in Fahey, who was interviewed by White House counsel and rated highly by a bipartisan judicial evaluation committee.
News: John Cornyn and Ted Cruz got into a heated shouting match on the Senate floor yesterday “I don’t find you credible!” “I’m mad at you!" “That’s bullshit!" Read all about their beef in The Stakeout: https://t.co/A7d9OddX1U
Disagreement on the Senate Floor
The tension between the two Texas Republicans reached a breaking point on Tuesday, when Senator Ted Cruz attempted to discuss the Gaiser nomination with Cornyn on the Senate floor. According to Newsweek, the interaction escalated into a shouting match. Cruz later said that Cornyn “began screaming” and “began cursing at me” after the nomination was raised.
Cruz linked the outburst to Cornyn’s primary defeat, stating, “Losing an election is hard, and people get upset about it.” During the argument, reporters in the press gallery heard Cornyn tell Cruz, “I don’t find you credible.” At one point, Cornyn remarked he was upset at someone “for ending my career,” though it remained unclear if he was referring to the president or Cruz.
Cruz has warned that the delay could have long-term consequences for the judiciary. “If the Senate Judiciary Committee does not move Gaiser forward, the people of Texas will pay the price because it will effectively give the judicial seat to the Democrats, who will keep it vacant in perpetuity,” Cruz said in a statement reported by the Washington Examiner.
Cruz argued that because Gaiser is a sitting senior Justice Department official, he is the only candidate whose background check is already complete, making him the only person who could realistically be confirmed before the new Congress takes over in January.
Sure sounds like Elliot Gaiser’s nomination is dead here, and @JohnCornyn lays out a persuasive case: 1) “He’s not from Texas. That’s a basic problem.” 2) “I’ve offered an alternative” nominee. 3) “There was no consultation whatsoever.” “The Senate is not supposed to be a… pic.twitter.com/almr3gcUp9
White House and Justice Department Responses
The Justice Department has criticized the senator’s stance, stating it is “deeply disappointing that Senator Cornyn would choose political obstruction over advancing a highly qualified nominee.” In a formal statement, the department described Gaiser as a “brilliant legal mind, a principled defender of the Constitution, and an outstanding judicial nominee.” The department further claimed that Cornyn’s “political antics only hurt the American public and the rule of law.” While the administration has signaled it expects to confirm its judicial picks before the current session ends in January, sources familiar with the process said that a new nominee would likely face significant delays due to the time required for FBI background checks.
Cornyn, meanwhile, has rejected the characterization that his actions are politically motivated, telling reporters that the Senate has a constitutional responsibility to provide “advice and consent,” which he argues is impossible without consultation.
In a post on X, he questioned the timing of the administration’s actions: “If President Trump wanted to fill a judicial vacancy in Dallas, why did he wait until after the midterms to nominate someone?” The seat has remained vacant since 2025. He also expressed sympathy for the nominee, telling reporters, “I kind of feel bad that he’s been used basically as a pawn in this process.”
Senators Debate Judicial Qualifications
Senator Ted Cruz, who personally interviewed Elliot Gaiser, described the nominee to Fox News as “incredibly principled, smart, capable, ready.” College President Larry Arnn also praised the candidate in an email to the Hillsdale Collegian, noting that Gaiser “respects the law deeply” and understands the fundamental principles of the Constitution.
While the White House has pushed for Gaiser’s confirmation, a spokesperson granted anonymity by Click2Houston said that the administration expects all of Trump’s judicial nominees to be confirmed by year’s end.
Cornyn, however, continues to advocate for Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey, telling the Detroit News that he sees interest from the White House regarding that alternative. He further told Fox News that he would still like to work with the President to fill the seat while Republicans maintain a Senate majority.

John Cornyn, who has served as the senior United States senator for Texas since 2002, wields this veto power through the blue slip tradition, a Senate Judiciary Committee practice that grants home-state senators the authority to block judicial nominees. By withholding his blue slip, Cornyn effectively halts the nomination process, preventing the candidate from moving forward for a committee vote.
This procedural tool has been a fixture of his long legislative tenure, which also included serving as the Senate Republican whip from 2013 to 2019. Drawing on his background as a former judge on Texas’s 37th District Court from 1985 to 1991, Cornyn asserts that this authority ensures nominees are properly vetted and possess adequate ties to the state.
Broader Political Friction
The dispute has drawn external criticism, including from Kevin Roberts, president of the Heritage Foundation. Roberts posted on X that Cornyn was going out as the senator who helped start the agenda of a “radical leftist,” to which Cornyn responded by calling Roberts “irrelevant” and claiming his “sycophancy has destroyed the credibility of a once great institution.” The conflict highlights the broader challenge facing Republican leadership as they attempt to confirm judges before the January transition.
Other senators, such as Thom Tillis of North Carolina, have also indicated they will oppose judicial nominees who lack support from their home-state Republican senators, complicating the push to fill vacancies.
John Cornyn is going out as the Republican Texas Senator who helped get radical leftist James Talarico’s agenda started early. What a legacy. pic.twitter.com/aoniaaBN9M