Sweeping reforms are needed to help 440,000 young people into work, according to a government-commissioned review published on Tuesday by former minister Alan Milburn.
Alan Milburn Proposes System Reset for Young People
A current rate of 13% is seen as roughly one million people aged 16 to 24 across the UK who are not engaged in education, employment or training. Milburn’s review aims to drive that figure down to around 5% within a decade, warning that extensive change is required to avoid a lost generation and address a moral crisis.
According to the findings in the review, during the 2024/25 period, £25 was allocated to youth benefits for every £1 spent on guiding young individuals toward employment or education. By 2036, the target ratio should shift to £2 on benefits for every £1 on work support.
Proposals Aim to Improve School Readiness and Youth Services
To reach these employment targets over the next decade, the proposals outline several key milestones. The recommendations call for 90% of children to be school-ready with basic life skills by five years old, a figure currently at 68% in England against a government target of 75% by 2028.
Additional measures include increased emphasis on work skills in the school curriculum, instant access to mental health support without a diagnosis, and doubling the number of young apprentices.
At the center of the recommendations for England is a legal entitlement to support delivered through a new Youth Opportunity Service. This service would assign a named adviser to help young individuals secure an apprenticeship, college place, supported employment, or a job within four months.
Replacing Health Top-Ups with New Youth Allowances
To finance the reforms, young adults would no longer receive the health top-up of Universal Credit, which provides extra money for individuals whose health conditions limit their capacity to work. Personal Independence Payment, which assists with the extra living costs of a long-term health condition or disability, would also be replaced for under-25s.
Instead, these benefits would be replaced with a new Youth Allowance at the base rate of Universal Credit alongside a new Additional Cost Allowance. A Severe and Complex Needs Insurance would support the minority of young people unable to work.
Kat, a 21-year-old from Devon who receives Universal Credit with the health top-up for fluctuating physical and mental health problems including functional neurological disorder, faces the possibility of receiving a lower level of benefits under the new framework. She said that she wants to work but must rely on welfare because she has been unable to find a safe employment environment.
Meanwhile, 19-year-old Josh has spent three years looking for work while on Universal Credit with assistance from the youth employment charity Spear. His experience reflects broader hurdles, as Grace Coates, who manages Spear St Helens, expressed a desire for increased openness from employers toward hiring individuals with limited experience.
Business Incentives and Existing Grants
The review also suggests lowering National Insurance rates paid by employers for young adult workers to make hiring them more attractive. Existing programs such as the Youth Jobs Grant, which gives employers £3,000 for hiring a young person who has been looking for work for six months, and the government-underwritten Jobs Guarantee, would be retained.
The government recently adjusted the Jobs Guarantee eligibility, allowing young adults to qualify after 12 months on Universal Credit rather than the current 18-month requirement.
Fiscal Analysis and Political Responses to Reforms
The Institute for Fiscal Studies said that reforms are more likely to succeed if employment support for young people is balanced with hiring incentives for businesses, cautioning that cutting benefit entitlements reduces immediate cash before employment increases can offset it.
Conservative shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately offered conditional backing while criticizing the financial approach:
Where Milburn gets it right, we’ll back him.
Helen Whately, Conservative shadow work and pensions secretary via BBC News
“fails to bring down the welfare bill, proposes billions more in government spending and won't make the slightest difference for young people stuck on welfare now” Conservative shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said of the document.
“only partly undo the damage of Labour's job tax” Liberal Democrat deputy leader Daisy Cooper said, suggesting instead that her party focuses on halting the Neets cycle at its origin by providing 18-year-olds with 100 hours of genuine work placement alongside a dedicated careers adviser for every individual.
Suella Braverman, the shadow education secretary for Reform UK, argued that a 10-year implementation schedule effectively abandons yet another generation to failure, maintaining that her party would immediately scrap Labour’s jobs tax, double the availability of apprenticeships, and terminate worthless university degree schemes that saddle students with heavy debt.
Green deputy leader Mothin Ali called the announced proposals extremely concerning, stating that “There is an alternative to threatening vulnerable people with benefits they need, an alternative to unsuitable short-term work.”
Earlier coverage: Alan Milburn Proposes Youth Benefit Overhaul