Character actor E.J. Carroll died suddenly at age 66 on Thursday while traveling to a voice-over appointment (according to his representative, Jon Mason of Mason-Lewis Entertainment).
Born on May 21, 1960, Carroll established a nearly three-decade career across television, feature films, short films, and video games. His television debut took place in 1998, when he portrayed a police officer in an episode of NBC’s Law & Order.
He subsequently returned to the franchise across multiple episodes, including appearances in Law & Order: SVU and Law & Order: Criminal Intent. His early career also included small parts in the 2001 film Pipe Dream and 2003’s Crooked Lines.
Television and Film Credits Across Three Decades
Throughout the 2000s and 2010s, Carroll built an extensive resume of guest and recurring roles on prominent television series. In 2012, he portrayed Sheriff Victor Sickles in two episodes of HBO’s Boardwalk Empire, created by Terence Winter, executive produced by Martin Scorsese, and starring Steve Buscemi.
His television work also included appearances on FX’s legal drama Damages alongside Glenn Close and Rose Byrne, alongside roles in The Blacklist, Blue Bloods, High Maintenance, and Pose. He also portrayed Doctor Charles in Marvel’s Netflix series The Punisher. Additionally, he appeared in several episodes of Adult Swim productions including The Heart, She Holler and Neon Joe, Werewolf Hunter.

One of his most recognizable television roles began in 2017, when he joined HBO’s The Deuce as Fat Mooney. The character operated a New York City sex shop owned by Frankie Martino, played by James Franco. Carroll appeared in multiple episodes across the series’ three-season run from 2017 to 2019.
On the big screen, Carroll appeared in Darren Aronofsky’s acclaimed 2009 sports drama The Wrestler, starring Mickey Rourke, as well as the drama Everybody’s Fine, starring Robert De Niro, Drew Barrymore, Kate Beckinsale, and Sam Rockwell. His film credits also included roles in The Cake Eaters, The Capers, The Winning Season, The Hungry Ghosts, and A Fish Story.
Voice Work and Posthumous Projects
Beyond live-action television and film, Carroll lent his voice to the blockbuster 2013 video game Grand Theft Auto V, where he voiced characters among the local population. In 2007, he also portrayed Dr. Scott in a one-night concert version of The Rocky Horror Show titled The Rocky Horror Tribute Show, which raised money for cancer charities Acting for a Cure and Komen for the Cure.

In October, the actor appeared in the movie The Mayflower, a 2026 production directed by Nick Sandow. Prior to his passing, Carroll filmed a role in the upcoming movie A Delicate Arrangement, a film directed by Nick Sandow and written by Jayce Bartok.
The project features Carla Gugino as the Gone With the Wind star Vivien Leigh, alongside Matthew Modine and David Hyde Pierce. Mason said that Carroll was deeply passionate about the film and helped ensure its completion.
His final work will also be shared posthumously across additional upcoming films, including Triumph of the Will and The Wretched Devours.
Tributes from the Acting Community
Representatives and colleagues remembered Carroll for his dedication to his craft and his presence within New York’s artistic community.
E.J. Carroll was a consummate actor known and loved for his intense commitment to the characters he played. There isn’t an actor in New York that hadn’t worked with or crossed paths with E.J. … He will be greatly missed by the acting community, which he lived for.
Jon Mason, representative at Mason-Lewis Entertainment, via Deadline
When E.J. Carroll performed, it was impossible to take your eyes off him. But his lasting legacy will be the kindness and generosity he showed his friends, fellow performers and even strangers. He was as good a human being as it gets.
Jon Mason, representative at Mason-Lewis Entertainment, via People