The film, which began streaming on Prime Video on November 18, stages a confrontation after the 1978 preseason hit that paralyzed Patriots receiver Darryl Stingley.
In the movie, Christian Bale’s Al Davis dismisses John Madden’s wish to visit Stingley in the hospital: “He’s not our player. We take care of ours, they take care of theirs. Okay?” Davis told USA TODAY Sports the scene never happened and contradicts his father’s actual legacy of assisting former players regardless of team affiliation.
Davis Says Film Misrepresents Father
Mark Davis screened the final cut two weeks before release and said he was blindsided by the Stingley sequence, which had not been discussed during earlier conversations with the filmmakers, according to USA Today.
“One of the main legacies of my father was how much he took care of people, whether it was on the Raiders or other teams,” Davis said.
“People that were ill or needed help or whatever. He helped so many players on other teams that it’s incredible. And he did it quietly.” He added that the filmmakers told him they would not change the scene. “That’s an example of characterization that hurt me,” Davis told the outlet.
Cage Chooses Interpretation Over Impression
Nicolas Cage, 62, acknowledged he knew nothing about John Madden before accepting the role. “He was not on my radar. I was growing up watching black-and-white Orson Welles movies and Fellini movies and Bruce Lee. I wasn’t interested in team sports whatsoever,” Cage told The Hollywood Reporter.

Director David O. Russell originally approached Cage to play Al Davis; Cage turned that down and agreed to play Madden instead, calling it a transformation that would push him out of his comfort zone.
Cage gained roughly 25 pounds for the part; prosthetics and makeup artist Adrien Morot — who worked on Brendan Fraser’s transformation in “The Whale” — accounted for the remaining weight to achieve a 60-pound look.
Cage said he studied Madden’s cadence but aimed for an “evocation, more or less, or an interpretation” rather than a mimicry. “I’m not an impressionist, I’m not Frank Caliendo,” Cage said.
“I lean more towards being a surrealist, meaning I like to get a concept of a personality and then dig deep and see what I can locate emotionally with my imagination and my psyche and filter it through the cadence and the appearance, within reason, of John Madden.”
On the voice specifically, Cage told The Hollywood Reporter: “I listened to his cadence, I located what I thought would be an interpretation within the realms of what was anatomically possible. I’m not going to let AI touch my voice or my appearance. I try to give you something which is an interpretation.” Comedian Frank Caliendo, known for his Madden impression, said filmmakers contacted him for a Zoom consultation but he declined, preferring to meet Cage in person; he never heard back.

Critics Pan Film; Historical Liberties Noted
Early reviews have been harsh. The film holds a 15% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and Yahoo Entertainment reported that Amazon pulled back its theatrical release.
Critics singled out Cage’s vocal performance and a narrative structure one outlet called “dizzying”. The A.V. Club labeled the attempt to tell Madden’s story “disastrous”.
Beyond the Stingley scene, the movie takes other liberties. It depicts Al Davis delivering his “Just win, baby” motto before Super Bowl XI in January 1977; the phrase was actually coined seven years later. It also shows Madden developing the video game concept in the “Madden Cruiser” bus circa 1979, though the bus did not exist until 1987 and the game’s design was hammered out on an Amtrak train ride in December 1984.
The film suggests Madden’s fear of flying stemmed from a Cal Poly football team plane crash, a connection not supported by the historical record.

Bale and Cage Reunite After 25 Years
The project marks the first on-screen reunion for Cage and Bale since 2001’s “Captain Corelli’s Mandolin.”
Bale, in his fourth collaboration with Russell following “The Fighter”, “American Hustle” and “Amsterdam”, said the two actors are “very different kinds of actors” who had a “great time riffing off of each other.”
“There’s no competition in that at all.” Bale added. He praised Russell’s approach: “When we approach a film, we always think this might just be the last one we ever get to make. That’s the right attitude to have with movies, and in the state of movies right now, it might very well be the truth.”
Al Davis, born in Brockton, Massachusetts, in 1929, never played varsity football but rose through coaching and scouting to become AFL commissioner in 1966.
He was the first modern NFL owner to hire a Black head coach, Art Shell, a female chief executive, Amy Trask, and a Latino head coach, Tom Flores. He remains the only person to have served as scout, assistant coach, head coach, general manager, league commissioner, and team owner.
Madden died in December 2021. The biopic, directed by David O. Russell and co-written and co-produced by him, is now streaming on Prime Video.