Republican Senator Bill Cassidy blocked President Donald Trump’s nominee to lead the National Science Foundation on Wednesday, ending Jim O’Neill’s bid for the independent federal research agency during a contentious Senate hearing on Capitol Hill.
The Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions met to vote on several nominees when the panel chair abruptly revised the agenda. Cassidy, a Republican from Louisiana, announced that the committee would not consider O’Neill for the top science post at an agency that has experienced budget cuts and grant freezes under the Trump administration. The National Science Foundation is an embattled independent federal agency.
Cassidy criticized O’Neill’s previous tenure in health agencies under the Trump administration.
Over the last several months, I have had several frank conversations with both Dr. Overton and Mr. O’Neill about their visions, roles, and the lack of trust that exists due to broken promises and irresponsible decisions from other officials within the Administration. I appreciate…
did not do enough to stand up for science
Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La.
Cassidy specifically pointed to O’Neill’s failure to push back against irresponsible decisions and statements from Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Cassidy also noted O’Neill’s role in the ouster of former CDC director Susan Monarez, who was forced out less than a month after her Senate confirmation. O’Neill took over the CDC leadership post after Monarez was fired for refusing to blindly approve vaccine recommendations from anti-vaccine advisors.
His role in the firing of Susan Monarez raised further concerns about the independent judgment he would bring to NSF.
Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La., via The Guardian
“I like Jim personally, but this time requires leadership and fortitude and standing up for what is right,” Cassidy said in his opening remarks before the committee.
O’Neill worked as a science and technology investor and entrepreneur, and became a close ally of Peter Thiel. Critics have said that he lacked the science experience needed to run the foundation, while the Trump administration has faced criticism for terminating all members of the National Science Board in April and canceling hundreds of research grants alongside budget and staff cuts driven by actions from Elon Musk’s DOGE.
The White House stood by the nomination despite the committee’s decision not to hold a vote, with the president having not formally withdrawn O’Neill’s nomination. White House spokesperson Allison Schuster defended O’Neill’s qualifications in a statement shared with reporters.

needs the leadership of Jim O’Neill, who has spent over a decade in the private sector helping to identify and finance cutting-edge technologies of the future.
Allison Schuster, White House Spokesperson
The committee’s rejection of O’Neill coincided with another personnel shift on Capitol Hill. On Tuesday, the White House withdrew the nomination of Dr. Heidi Overton, who had been expected to run the Food and Drug Administration.
Cassidy described the decision to yank the nomination as pretty odd and suggested that anti-abortion senators seeking final assurances from the administration caused the reversal.
The last issue was that pro-life Senators sought final assurances from the Administration regarding the Administration’s commitment to life issues, The Administration withdrew Dr. Overton rather than make such commitments.
Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La.
With Overton’s nomination abandoned and O’Neill’s confirmation halted, Cassidy said that confirming a permanent FDA commissioner will unfortunately fall to Senate Democrats given the limited time left as the Republican-led Senate pushes through confirmation hearings before losing the majority in January.