Thursday, November 19, 2026 Latest Pastor Christian Emmanuel Sanon Convicted in Plot to Kill Jovenel Moïse Our standards
World

Su. Venkatesan Slams Judge, Says Spiritual Remedies Are Not a Judge’s Role

Madurai MP Su. Venkatesan criticized G.R. Swaminathan on Monday, stating that suggesting remedies for corruption is not the role of a judge.

Su. Venkatesan Slams Judge, Says Spiritual Remedies Are Not a Judge's Role
Su. Venkatesan Slams Judge, Says Spiritual Remedies Are Not a Judge's Role

Madurai MP Su. Venkatesan criticized G.R. Swaminathan on Monday, stating that suggesting remedies for corruption is not the role of a judge.

The controversy stems from the Periyar Library in Coimbatore, which is set to be inaugurated by Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Vijay on October 16. Writer Perumal Murugan publicly accused officials of corruption in the procurement of books for the facility. The accusations quickly triggered a political clash, with the ruling Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK) and the opposition Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) exchanging mutual blame over the procurement scandal.

Amid the growing fallout, G.R. Swaminathan attended a book release event for Maha Periyava, authored by P. Swaminathan and published by Thamarai Press Media. During the event, he addressed the procurement scandal at the Periyar Library. He suggested that to cleanse the library of sins stemming from books supplied by Agal Vilakku Publications, authorities should place all books of Maha Periyava on its shelves.

Su. Venkatesan Slams Judge, Says Spiritual Remedies Are Not a Judge's Role
Photo: Dinamani

Su. Venkatesan said, “That is the job of astrologers.”

MP Su. Venkatesan responded sharply to the remarks, arguing that suggesting spiritual remedies for wrongdoing falls outside the scope of the judiciary. The legislator emphasized that corruption in public procurement is a legal offense that demands judicial punishment rather than ritualistic penance.

What has happened in the library procurement is corruption, and it must be punished according to the law. That is the work of judges. Saying that a sin has been committed and that atonement must be performed for it is the work of astrologers.

Su. Venkatesan, Madurai MP

The lawmaker added that society relies on the wisdom of B.R. Ambedkar for the rule of law and Periyar for rational thought, maintaining a clear separation between legal accountability and moral or religious remedies.

During the book release event, G.R. Swaminathan also recounted his handling of a related library corruption case. He said that he presided over a book corruption petition originally filed in 2019, reviewing the matter in 2024. He said that the earlier procurement involved a book titled Veeram Vilainja Mann, which he identified as Kalki’s Sivagamiyin Sabatham with a modified title and cover to secure library orders illegally.

He said that merely issuing a government order for transparent procurement does not erase past offenses. Pointing out that irregularities persisted into 2025 despite prior judicial directives, G.R. Swaminathan scheduled the ongoing matter for further hearings.

Accuracy matters. See something that needs attention? Read our corrections policy or contact the newsroom.

World Editor

Samira Rahman

Samira Rahman leads TellingPointy's World desk. Her coverage follows diplomacy, conflict, migration, security, climate, and global institutions through the decisions that shape public life, distinguishing verified developments from unconfirmed claims.