Westminster MP Sir Andrew Mitchell says Guernsey and Jersey’s new plans for company ownership registers “do not go nearly far enough,” warning that access limits could leave national security threats invisible to investigators.
The criticism landed on November 22 after both Crown Dependencies published consultation responses. The plans would allow journalists, academics and civil society researchers to apply for access to beneficial ownership data — but only after clearing a “legitimate interest” test that Mitchell argues creates a catch-22 for anyone trying to prove wrongdoing in the first place.
- Plans follow a joint December 2023 commitment by Guernsey, Jersey and the Isle of Man.
- Jersey requires applicants to exhaust “all reasonable alternative sources” first; Guernsey does not mirror that rule.
- Both governments reject the criticism and cite international compliance standards.
- Implementation is expected in 2027.
Proposals create a catch-22
Currently, beneficial ownership information in Guernsey and Jersey is available only to law enforcement, regulators and certain regulated businesses conducting anti-money laundering checks. The new framework would widen that circle to approved applicants — journalists, academics and others with a “legitimate interest” in investigating suspected financial crime.
Mitchell, who has campaigned for greater scrutiny of company ownership, said the proposals contain “immediate indications” they will fall short. He argued that investigators could face a “catch-22” because they may need register access to prove wrongdoing before they can qualify for that access.

Jersey’s consultation response explicitly requires applicants to show that “all reasonable alternative sources have been exhausted” before access is granted. Guernsey’s published response does not include the same requirement.
Mitchell also questioned whether users would have to pay for access, and urged that the proposals should eventually lead to fully public registers open to investigators, particularly those from developing nations.
Island governments push back
Both governments rejected Mitchell’s characterization. A Government of Jersey spokesperson said his concerns “do not accurately reflect what is in Jersey’s consultation response paper” and said the policy was designed to meet international commitments while maintaining “a fair, proportionate, and effective transparency framework”. The spokesperson added: “Jersey continues to meet international standards for transparency and countering money laundering, terrorist financing and proliferation financing.”
Guernsey’s Policy & Resources Committee, through Deputy Andrew Niles, pointed to a positive 2025 assessment of the island’s financial crime prevention efforts. “Guernsey does not accept the suggestion that our proposals fall short of the commitments we’ve made on beneficial ownership transparency or that the island does not meet international standards on beneficial ownership transparency”, Niles said.
He described the framework as “based on a tried and tested model adopted in the EU”, designed to protect privacy and vulnerable individuals while providing access for legitimate investigations.
Two philosophies, one register
Westminster’s transparency camp argues that application-based gates — especially exhaustion requirements — turn a promising reform into a bureaucratic maze that slows down scrutiny on deadline. The islands counter that privacy and data protection are not imaginary problems: an open register without safeguards risks scraping, harassment and targeted scams, while a gate built too high risks legal challenges and administrative bottlenecks.
Guernsey officials cited a positive 2025 assessment of the island’s financial crime prevention efforts as evidence that law enforcement already has strong tools without a fully public database.
Westminster MP Sir Andrew Mitchell, who served as Minister of State for Development and Africa from October 2022 to July 2024 and as Deputy Foreign Secretary from April to July 2024, has campaigned for greater scrutiny of company ownership for years. His frontbench experience overseeing international development and foreign policy gave him direct exposure to how opaque corporate structures in Crown Dependencies facilitate illicit finance flowing from developing nations.
Mitchell, the MP for Sutton Coldfield since 2001 and previously Shadow Foreign Secretary from July to November 2024, argues that the islands’ new application-based access regimes create a catch-22: investigators need register data to prove wrongdoing but must prove wrongdoing to qualify for that data.
Implementation arrives in 2027
The next test comes when Guernsey and Jersey implement their frameworks in 2027. That rollout will serve as a real-world case study for whether targeted, application-based transparency actually catches financial crime or simply slows down scrutiny.
For anyone tracking entities in the Channel Islands, the practical steps are already clear: map beneficial owners now, confirm records are current, and plan due diligence around application-based rules, identity verification and strict limits on how data can be used or shared. Pair corporate filings with sanctions screening, court records and broader financial context — never rely on one registry alone.