Four major AI assistants failed to find reliable 55-inch television deals on Black Friday.
AI Assistants Fail the TV Shopping Test
When four major AI assistants were asked to find a good deal on a 55-inch television a week before Black Friday, the tools returned a tangled mix of correct pricing, sold-out stock, dead links, and outdated offers from the previous year. The test, conducted by the BBC using free versions of popular conversational models, exposed persistent flaws in how artificial intelligence handles live retail data.
OpenAI’s ChatGPT presented four options. Its top recommendation for a Hisense television on Chinese retailer Joybuy’s website was unlisted at both retailers. A second recommendation for a TCL model featured a sidebar displaying prices for a smaller 50-inch version, ranging from £379 to £814.
A third pick—the same Hisense model at full price from John Lewis and Richer Sounds—was labeled as the “best safer purchase” due to longer guarantees, but both retailers confirmed the set was no longer available online. A fourth option sat £150 over budget, while the bottom of the list featured “one OLED option to compare”—an LG television priced at £1,100 and marked as an advertisement.
Claude delivered the shortest response with minimal technical specifications, relying instead on a small pool of published reviews. It suggested two TCL televisions, but the provided links directed testers to dead pages on Richer Sounds and round-ups of Black Friday 2025 deals.
Gemini produced a comparative table for four sets without including any URLs, forcing testers to conduct their own searches. One recommended TCL was correctly priced at £649 but sold out, while another was listed at £539 for Argos and Currys—a correct figure for Argos, but £60 higher at Currys.
Amazon’s Alexa, which searches only Amazon, returned accurate prices ranging from £532 for its own Ember brand to £616 for a reduced Samsung, though its fourth option was a 50-inch Sony rather than the requested 55-inch size.
Stale Data Breaks Shopping Bots
The exercise showed how quickly chatbot recommendations disconnect from reality. Naureen Mohammed, an adviser who helps businesses optimize their visibility in AI search results, said that retailers failing to refresh catalogues make systems serve old figures as new promotions.
Consumer Adoption Trends Across Global Markets
These technology limits match low public trust in automated shopping tools in the UK. A YouGov survey spanning 19 countries revealed that the UK ranked second-last in the proportion of respondents reporting prior use of AI for shopping assistance. 36% of people planning to shop during the retail event indicated no intention of using an AI tool.
Amazon introduced Alexa for Shopping for UK users in November. OpenAI debuted its Shopping Research utility on ChatGPT ahead of the previous year’s shopping period. Google deployed its Universal Cart in the US to support price tracking and promotional code identification.

The BBC, which conducted the test using free versions of the conversational models, was established in 1922 as the British Broadcasting Company before becoming a public corporation under royal charter on 1 January 1927.
It is the oldest and largest broadcaster by number of employees, with a total staff of 22,000, and is funded principally by an annual television licence fee charged to UK households. Since 1 April 2014, that fee has also funded the BBC World Service, launched in 1932 as the BBC Empire Service, which broadcasts in 43 languages.
Despite consumer hesitation, technology platforms continue rolling out commercial features. Amazon introduced Alexa for Shopping for UK users in November, OpenAI debuted its Shopping Research utility on ChatGPT ahead of the previous year’s shopping period, and Google deployed its Universal Cart in the US to support price tracking and promotional code identification.
Earlier coverage: Police and Experts Warn of AI-generated Storefronts Ahead of Black Friday