Traditional credit scores are “backward looking” according to Funmi Olufunwa, a consumer finance lawyer and founder of financial education business Hoops Finance.
Traditional Credit Score Failures
Getting approval for a mortgage, car loan, or mobile phone contract often depends on a credit score. These scores do not always tell the full story.
“When I first checked my credit score, it was excellent. But then my mortgage application was suddenly denied by the lender because of my credit report. It was a massive shock as I'd never had bad credit. When I looked into it, my score had gone to 'very poor'” Sophie Hope said. This resulted in a sudden mortgage application denial from her lender.
“Without me knowing, the debt was transferred to a secondary finance company. It spent three to four years accumulating in the background. It was only when I went to apply for a mortgage that I discovered how severely it had dragged down my credit score” Sophie Hope said.
Evangeline Atkinson found herself completely invisible to the system while at university. This led to a rejected phone contract because no record of her existed at any of the big three credit reference agencies—Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion.
Traditional credit scoring in the UK relies on the big three firms working from roughly the same data. US lending decisions often hinge on a credit score from FICO using data from those major assessment firms.
Artificial Intelligence and Alternative Lenders
AI-powered lending firms like Upstart and Zest AI offer lenders an alternative option for assessing credit worthiness. Upstart said that its machine-learning models evaluate more than 2,500 variables.
Alternative platforms such as Noggin HQ—founded by Atkinson in 2021 and authorised by the FCA in June—also give lenders an option. Noggin HQ helps lenders interpret thousands of individual data points regarding spending habits by analysing current account transactional data without using AI.
Atkinson said that AI carries the risk of inbuilt bias. Sensitive data makes it easy for models to infer protected characteristics.
Based in Newcastle, Noggin HQ was established by childhood friends Evangeline Atkinson and Laura Mills after both founders were turned down for credit despite being in full-time employment and paying rent and bills. The company is one of only a handful of firms to secure a license to operate as a credit reference agency in the UK over the past decade.
Traditional scoring companies are beginning to experiment with AI. Experian announced a partnership with OpenAI in August 2026, allowing users to check their credit score inside ChatGPT, as reported by Finwire.