Sunday, November 22, 2026 Latest Nicalis Removes AI-Generated Music From Binding of Isaac Our standards
Technology

Nicalis Removes AI-Generated Music From Binding of Isaac

A free update for The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ was review-bombed on Steam after players discovered undisclosed AI-generated music in a new Grand Theft Auto-themed mode, prompting developer Nicalis to strip the tracks from the game within hours.

Nicalis Removes AI-Generated Music From Binding of Isaac
Nicalis Removes AI-Generated Music From Binding of Isaac

A free update for The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ was review-bombed on Steam after players discovered undisclosed AI-generated music in a new Grand Theft Auto-themed mode, prompting developer Nicalis to strip the tracks from the game within hours.

The update launched on November 19, 2026, after months of buildup from series creator Edmund McMillen and publisher Nicalis. It brought Repentance+ to Nintendo Switch 2, PlayStation 5, and Xbox Series X/S while giving existing PC players a free patch.

Patch notes on Steam invited players to enter the seed V1CE BSMT for a “crime-packed surprise” — a GTA-inspired daily run with special weapons and 14 music files, including seven full songs plus intros and outros.

Reddit User Exposes AI Metadata in Audio Files

One day after launch, Reddit user ShweetsStuff posted a breakdown alleging the new tracks were created with Suno, an AI music generator. The user pointed to metadata embedded in the audio files.

One file, drivingsong1.ogg, carried a comment field reading made with suno; created=2026-10-30T17:53:41Z; id=cd5a5b55-bead-4cb9-949d-09ed1f917dce. Other files had the metadata scrubbed but were derived from the same source. Kotaku reproduced the ffprobe output and said that common tools such as VLC can display the comments.

The music was exclusive to the GTA-themed run and did not replace the game’s wider soundtrack. However, the Steam store page had not been updated to disclose AI use, as Valve requires for games that incorporate AI-generated assets during development.

The binding of isaac repentance ai
Photo: IGN

Steam Reviews Plummet After AI Music Revelation

Negative reviews flooded Steam. By November 21, only 8% of recent reviews were positive, placing the game in the “Overwhelmingly Negative” category. Reviewers criticized both the AI music and the lack of disclosure.

— a popular Steam review quoted by IGN

— another Steam review quoted by IGN

Complaints also referenced bugs, latency, and quality-control issues that had been building before the AI discovery, according to Kotaku.

McMillen Responds and Nicalis Patches Out AI Tracks

On November 21, McMillen posted on X:

“Woke up to a shit show, obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run, looking into how that happened and getting it removed, stay tuned.”

Nicalis removes AI music from The Binding of Isaac after player backlash
Photo: Superpower Daily

— Edmund McMillen, creator of The Binding of Isaac

Hours later, Nicalis released a patch confirming the “removal of generated music files.” The fix is live on PC. The studio said it has submitted the patch to Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony, but has not given a date for console rollout.

Nicalis did not explain how or why the AI music was included, stating only that it was “working on the game and will continue to address new and old bugs.” McMillen encouraged players to report issues to the developers.

Edmund McMillen, creator of The Binding of Isaac since its 2011 debut, confirmed on November 21, 2026, that he “had no idea” the update included AI-generated music in the new daily run, revealing he was not consulted on the asset selection.

Nicalis, the publisher handling console ports and patch deployment, issued the removal patch hours later and managed submissions to Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony without a stated console rollout date, while McMillen directed players to report issues to the developers.

As of the latest reports, recent Steam reviews remain “Overwhelmingly Negative.”

Accuracy matters. See something that needs attention? Read our corrections policy or contact the newsroom.

Technology Editor

Maya Serrano

Maya Serrano leads TellingPointy's Technology desk, covering artificial intelligence, platforms, software, hardware, cybersecurity, and digital policy. Her reporting translates complex technical systems while examining governance, incentives, and real-world limits.